Articles

Traditional Restriction Cloning

Digestion, gel extraction, vector dephosphorylation, T4 DNA ligase kinetics, and reading frame scars

Molecular Cloning

Traditional Restriction Cloning

Traditional restriction cloning is the method molecular biology was built on. You open a vector at a known restriction site, put your gene in, and seal the join with a ligase.

Seamless methods now do most of the work in synthetic biology. Traditional cloning remains the cheapest way to move a gene from one plasmid to another. A pair of standard restriction enzymes and T4 DNA ligase cost a fraction of a proprietary assembly mix, so a lab doing routine subcloning in volume keeps its reagent bill small.

This guide covers the workflow, the two decisions that determine whether it works, and the three failures that waste the most time.

At a glance

  • Workflow: Choose the sites, digest vector and insert, ligate, transform.
  • Main constraint: You are limited to restriction sites that already exist where you need them, and they have to be unique.
  • Watch for: Vector self-ligation, and the scar each junction leaves in your reading frame.

Plan it first

The limitation of this method is that it depends on sequences you did not choose. You need sites in the right places, they need to be unique, and an enzyme that also cuts inside your target gene will cut your insert in two. Mapping the sites is the first thing to do, and it is covered in Restriction Enzymes Explained.

Two decisions follow, and both are easier on screen than at the bench:

  1. One enzyme or two: Two enzymes that leave incompatible ends set the orientation of your insert and stop the backbone closing on itself, which prevents the vector self-ligation behind most empty-vector colonies. Not every pair gives incompatible ends, so check the overhangs rather than assuming.
  2. What the junction does to your protein: Restriction cloning leaves a few bases of scar at each join, and those bases are part of your construct. In Photo51 you can build the finished plasmid, translate across both junctions, and see whether your insert is in frame and what the scar adds. This is the check worth doing twice. A frameshift cannot be fixed at the bench, and everything else about your experiment will appear to work.

Step 1: Digest

Digest your vector backbone and insert with your chosen enzymes. Type II enzymes cut the backbone to leave compatible ends, either short single-stranded overhangs, known as sticky ends, or blunt ends.

A typical digest runs at 37 °C for an hour, though the optimum varies by enzyme, so check the supplier's conditions and the limits on enzyme volume.

Afterwards you need to remove the enzymes, the buffer and any unwanted fragments. Most researchers run the digest on an agarose gel and extract the correct band on a silica column. This also separates your linearized backbone from any uncut supercoiled plasmid, which is worth doing even when the digest looks complete.

Step 2: Ligate

Mix the cut, purified fragments with T4 DNA ligase. Compatible ends find each other and base-pair, and the ligase forms the phosphodiester bonds that close the backbone.

Blunt-end ligations have nothing holding the fragments together while the ligase works, so they are much less efficient. Buffers for these reactions often contain polyethylene glycol, usually PEG 4000, which improves blunt-end efficiency.

The reaction responds to the molar ratio of the fragments, not their mass. A 3:1 insert-to-vector molar ratio is a common starting point. Because a concentration in ng/µL measures mass, convert using each fragment's length:

ng of insert = ng of vector × (insert length in bp ÷ vector length in bp) × molar ratio

Incubation conditions vary by protocol: room temperature for a few hours, 16 °C overnight, or a short incubation with a quick-ligation mix all work. When the reaction is done, your plasmid is ready to transform into competent E. coli.

You can also simulate restriction digests and cloning directly in software: see our video walkthrough on Restriction Cloning in Photo51.

Troubleshooting

Hundreds of colonies, and every one is empty vector

Symptom: Your plate is full, but colony PCR shows the backbone with no insert.

Cause: The vector closed back on itself during the ligation.

Fix: Cut with two different enzymes that leave incompatible ends. The backbone then cannot self-ligate, and your insert can only go in one way round. If only one enzyme is available, treat the digested vector with an alkaline phosphatase such as rSAP or CIP to remove its 5' phosphates, so it can only close if a phosphorylated insert bridges the gap. Also check for uncut template surviving from an incomplete digest, since it gives the same result.

Zero colonies

Symptom: You followed the protocol, the cells are competent, and the plate is bare.

Cause: Often the ligase buffer rather than the ligation. T4 DNA ligase needs ATP, the buffer supplies it, and ATP degrades with repeated freeze-thaw cycles or time at room temperature.

Fix: Aliquot the buffer into single-use tubes when it arrives. Discard a tube that has been thawed many times, has been open for months, or smells strongly of sulfur, which suggests the DTT has broken down. Run a ligation control with a vector and insert you know work, so you can rule the buffer in or out before you start changing anything else.

The insert is there and the protein is not

Symptom: Sequencing confirms that your insert is present and correct, but the bacteria do not express the protein.

Cause: The scar at the restriction site shifted the reading frame, which can also introduce a premature stop codon.

Fix: You cannot repair a frameshift at the bench, so this has to be caught in the design. Translate the construct in your software before you order anything, and check each junction: where your insert continues an upstream coding sequence, such as a tag, the scar between them has to be a multiple of three bases for the reading frame to carry through. This is the failure that makes traditional cloning expensive, because everything about the experiment works except the protein you wanted.